When Bex finds the right one, she realizes that Andi is not there to see and holds off on buying it, deciding to show it to her later. Andi ends up finding another dress that both Bex and Celia agree is the one. Andi feels uncomfortable at first, when she sees the apartment rearranged and her parents pampered by Cookie. They see one with the yin-yang symbol, which they believe perfectly represents Bowie. Brittany sees the note and reminds her who Bowie is. Buffy is the most disturbed about what she finds out and hopes it will not come true, about her mother being deployed again.
Bowie discovers Shaun is only taking lessons to please his father, but notices that Shaun's father, Victor, is passionate about the guitar and gives him a lesson. After recruiting her and seeing her impressive play, Buffy sees Kira's attitude about teamwork as a problem and cuts her from the team. Meanwhile, Bowie runs into Miranda and Morgan again. Cyrus prepares for his and has Jonah look over his wardrobe of suits. Metcalf, takes over at Andi's school. After Bex lets one fly, Andi goes to retrieve it and then sees Amber with a guy, but it is not Jonah.
Cyrus brags about the kiss next day to Andi, Buffy and even Jonah but admits that he doesn't remember how it was; he's just glad he's had his first kiss. This leads to her not hanging out with Andi, who starts asking questions after she sees Buffy and Bex talking at the Fringe. Jonah promises to be there for Amber during this tough time. Unsure whether he does, Andi races over to where the video is being shot, only to hear from Natalie that Jonah is going to the singalong, so she races back to catch the bus, which she almost misses. With Bex's help, they stage a protest at the school, with the participating students wearing prison outfits. Iris reveals that broke up with Amber last night. After they say goodbye, she resigns to Andi Shack and finds Celia in there, who is dealing with Ham being away, so the two console each other.
Jonah tells Andi about his breakup with Amber. On February 13, 2018, shared a script from the season finale of , episode 226. Meanwhile, Andi notices a girl with Jonah, but her attempt to talk to her goes unanswered. Then suddenly, there's all new territory for Andi to navigate - the possibility that Jonah Beck might like her, too. Meanwhile, Celia is insistent on a traditional wedding for Bex and decides to set a date without her consent. Despite her comment, Buffy is against the idea and feels disinclined to say goodbye to her friends.
Bowie attempts to teach a musical hopeful named Shaun, discovering he is no prodigy like Jonah. Buffy becomes a friend to her neighbor Millie through a community service project she is doing for school. Andi later gets a visit from Walker, who tells her that Buffy did not want him to come to the color factory, so she tells him he can go. Ham tells Bex that the man who fathered Andi knows she exists, because he told him. Miranda promises Bowie that she has improved her parenting, but Bowie sees that overall, she and her daughter have not changed. While Cyrus is somewhat happy about seeing Andi and Jonah together again, he reveals to Buffy that he is also unhappy because he has romantic feelings for Jonah. The scene ends just as Andi is about to tell them Bex's answer to Bowie's proposal.
Just as they are ready to head for the alpine slide, Buffy and Cyrus discover their bikes are missing. Jonah then gives her the bracelet that she had made for him - the one he had given to Amber. Andi invites Jonah to the new year event, but his not understanding the customs puts Celia on edge, as well as the idea of Andi even having a boyfriend. . When they talk about Jonah, though, Andi tells Libby not to let her stand in the way of dating him.
She accuses Morgan of taking it after searching thoroughly and tells Bowie, who has a hard time believing her. When that backfires, Celia finds another way to get her daughter noticed, by buying The Fringe, which has been struggling financially. Metcalf about making the policy more reasonable. It follows 13-year-old Andi Mack and her best friends, Cyrus Goodman and Buffy Driscoll, as they attend. Without even saying it, Buffy offers all the support Cyrus needs. After chaos ensues in the cafeteria over cookies, Dr. Andi enjoys the date and asks Jonah on another one, but he declines because he is going to an eight-week camp to improve his Ultimate skills.
Andi later talks to Jonah and wants their relationship to grow without Amber standing in the way. Still, there is hope when Andi sees Bowie unexpectedly take a ring out of one of the blazers he is trying on at a vintage store. Cyrus tells her that the other day, he wasn't really happy for Andi and Jonah getting together. Cyrus and Iris spend an evening together at her house and watch a movie, but he becomes uncomfortable following a kiss with her and decides to leave. Although Jonah says nothing is going on, Buffy warns him not to hurt Andi, causing him to leave the diner. Buffy gets into trouble at school over her curly hair and is told by the vice principal to change it.
Bowie does not want to make a big deal out of it, but Andi wants to throw him a huge surprise party at Celia and Ham's place. Andi continues to worry and feels Jonah is avoiding her when she later gets no response to her texts. Buffy starts the girls' basketball team but struggles as its captain. He gives Cyrus an official Space Otters team jersey. Andi tells her friends Cyrus and Buffy that she has joined the school frisbee team with Jonah, but has yet to tell them about the more important, life-changing discovery concerning her and Bex. Cyrus is still worried about how he will tell everyone else but Buffy assures him that it will be okay.
Even Amber cannot cheer him up, with her friend Kip belittling the sport he loves. Andi and Jonah finally talk about what is going on, but after Andi says her feelings for him have changed, Jonah suffers a panic attack. Cyrus and Buffy eventually get back to Andi's revelation and have some questions about it. When it comes time for Jonah to perform, he nervously struggles through his song until he looks at Andi. She has Bex work out the details, while she attends a Renaissance Festival for most of the day with her friends.