Madison invites Ricky to join them at the Boulderly Hills Country Club mini golf course but he doesn't take the offer right away. Then their class repeatedly repeats the phrase when the quads say it to them after they keep saying repeat it. To complete it, one has to get a date, hold hands romantically and look into each other's eyes. Natlee and June also push Dawn into breaking the quad pact by making her go to the concert with them. However, wishing to avoid arguing and noise in the early hours of Tom and Anne's anniversary, the punishment is lifted for Saturday morning. A Nickelodeon show about the eponymous set of 10-year-old quadruplets.
They discover that the new neighbors have a child named Syd and begin plotting on how to use her for their own needs. Unfortunately, the Harpers are invited by Aunt Jackie to visit her at her farm which has no Internet access to post the quadgoals picture. Dawn brings back from the party a life-sized mannequin that looked like Ricky after he disappeared during the magician's trick. Millie is a flight simulator, but Dawn assumes that Millie is another girl. Even though the parents discover what happened, the mother still allows them to keep the puppy because they worked together in the cover-up. Dooley gets them an ear piercer and a snake. The only thing stopping them is their missing practice skates.
The mother wanted to see if Dawn would try to get the bracelet back. Am I not coming in? Dawn is shocked to realize that Millie is a flight simulator. The quads want to pull an epic stunt for their class to be remembered by. The quads become so nervous that they barely sleep that night. Meanwhile, her brothers have realized that they need Dawn to keep themselves from fighting with one another, but they, like Dawn, refuse to admit defeat.
Their communication channel with the station is interrupted, making it impossible to get instructions on how to get back. Meanwhile, Tom and Anne find a bunch of their junk in the attic and also participate in the quads' challenge. At the end, the quads but still decide that they still want to be friends with her. Ricky is in a number of clubs at school including the Japanese club and he was elected his grade's student body president, which he took very seriously. When the drone flies out of the window, they discover a lot of bikes in Dooley's backyard. Of course, the ceiling also failed when they were together. The quads also offer to build Mrs.
They later realize it was a misunderstanding. One of the contests is to see who can get from one point to another. The coach comes back on a wheelchair and overhears them. Dawn confronts Ricky about the move, especially since Avery has a very bad exaggerated Valley girl accent. Meanwhile, Tom breaks Anne's vase while competing with her in the living room, and the two get into an argument.
A talented ballerina in the class, Eiffel, says that she needs the boys to make her look good and tells Dawn not to come back to class without them. So, he takes a picture that Dicky painted and claims it as his own. All the children at the party like Ricky, Dicky and Dawn's costumes, but hate Nicky's costume because he doesn't have a good superpower. The next day at school, they make an attempt at introducing themselves to Syd, but she's not interested and leaves. Madison says it's only cheating if anyone sees it.
Nicky says he wanted to ask Natlee, but Natlee wanted Dooley to ask her to the dance and things get out of control. However, things go awry when Nicky, Ricky, and Dicky also become sick and then later all four of them get stuck inside a caveman exhibit after trying to find a soundproof place to sneeze all they want. Things fimally fall apart when the real owner of the pig sees it with Anne. Unfortunately, he starts telling the class embarrassing stories about the quads as little children, so with Anne's help, the quads convince Principal Tarian to fire Tom and hire Anne instead. When she, Ricky, and Dicky start throwing it at each other, Nicky tries to warn them that they'll get rashes. Their heavy weight causes them to sled faster than the Kramdens and beat them in their sleep.
During Dawn's first night in her own room, she begins noticing frightening things, having never slept in a room without her brothers before; however, she is too stubborn to admit that she misses her brothers and begins to lose sleep. Later shortened to Squishy Paws. Unfortunately, Rose gets hurt on stage, so the director casts Dawn as the new Dorothy. The kids admit that there's nothing embarrassing about going to movies with their parents. After overpowering her brothers and gaining entry into the simulator, she agrees that it was totally worth it. They even conduct a research which reveals that their parents are the problem. The quads then get into an argument, with Ricky pretending to be Nicky, Dicky, and Dawn and mocking them, and Nicky, Dicky, and Dawn pretending to be Ricky and mocking him.